My name is Lauren Grant and this blog is a project for the University of Mary Washington. In this project I will focus on the life and career of Elizabeth Blackwell.
Elizabeth Blackwell was born in the 1800′s when women were rarely even allowed a proper education, let alone a career. Her religious family, however, believed that all people were equal and gave her an excellent education and raised her to believe that everyone deserved respect and equal opportunity. As an adult, she became the first woman physician and set groundbreaking pathways for future women in the medical field.
I was drawn towards researching Elizabeth Blackwell because I am interested in pursuing a medical career and I found her story to be inspiring and hoped to gain insight from her life.
Elizabeth Blackwell went on to try and fail almost thirty times to enter a medical college after deciding medicine was her calling in life. After finally being accepted to a college as a practical joke, Elizabeth was able to attain her degree, but not without many hardships to overcome, mostly revolving around her gender as a female.
Elizabeth Blackwell is honored with the privilege of being the first recognized female doctor. She was the first woman to receive a medical degree. She set up a hospital for women, run by women nurses and doctors to help women patients feel more at ease, as well as a college for women to study medicine, although it was only open for thirty years. In her later life- Elizabeth taught at a college in England and continued to inspire women to advance in their chosen field of work. One of her mentionable successes was her push for hygienic awareness. She tried to spread the word that poor health was not due to an angry god or bad luck, but rather due to unsanitary habits, which took a toll on the body. She realized well before many other doctors that illness treatment and prevention rested solely on sanitary habits.
Elizabeth Blackwell had to work harder than any man to earn the recognition and success that she did. Her life revolved around her fierce desire to help women progress into the field of medical work. Elizabeth’s beliefs were not the stereotypical harsh feminist beliefs that her other aspiring colleges possessed. Elizabeth used her femininity and nurturing to her advantage. She believed that a woman’s instinct to care was what made women better suited for the medical field. She wanted all of her students to aspire to heal and cure the sick as a doctor would, not take care of them while they were ill as was a nurse’s job. Elizabeth used her medical education and work as a barrier to keep her protected from marriage and the possibility or dependence on a man. She never married but did adopt an Irish orphan whom she raised by herself.
I believe that Elizabeth Blackwell is a role model that anyone could relate to. The judgments and barriers she had to push through to become the famous and successful FIRST woman doctor are tremendous. Her perseverance is something to be admired, but her success is almost unimaginable for the time period in which she lived. As a role model, she never denied her womanhood or was ashamed of her gender, she worked as hard an anyone despite the obstacles that society placed upon her and she took steps to create places where other women could achieve their goals as a doctor. I think she would have been honored to be a role model, in that time period as well as in ours.
In the 1800’s, a male counterpart to Elizabeth Blackwell was a French physician named Rene Laennec. I selected this man to study because he displayed many similar characteristics to Elizabeth Blackwell and because they were born in roughly the same time period.
Like Blackwell, Rene Laennec was European his career boasted positions of professor, doctor, and running a health clinic. Despite their difference in gender, Laennec and Blackwell were both exceptional doctors who made impacts on society and the health profession.
Gender did influence the careers of these two physicians. Had they had careers today, gender would not have affected their success or acceptance in to the medical community, however because of the bias towards male professionals in the 1800’s, Elizabeth Blackwell received less opportunity and recognition for her work. Laennec was accepted in the medical community and didn’t have to fight for a place at a medical college like Blackwell did because she was a female. Gender affected the success of both physicians because Blackwell, unlike Laennec, was much more hard pressed to find clients, preventing her medical practice and college from succeeding in the long term.
The Association of Women’s Health, Obstetric and Neonatal Nurses (AWHONN) was
formed in 1969 and still exists. Its mission was to “improve and promote the health of women and newborns and to strengthen the nursing profession through delivery of superior advocacy”
Core Values (as expressed in the acronym “CARING”)
ò Commitment to professional and social responsibility
ò Accountability for personal and professional contributions
ò Respect for diversity of and among colleagues and clients
ò Integrity in exemplifying the highest standards in personal and professional behavior
ò Nursing Excellence for quality outcomes in practice, education, research, advocacy and management
ò Generation of Knowledge to enhance the science and practice of nursing to improve the health of women and newborns
This association provides support and career advancement to women in the medical field, particularly nurses. It is a good source of encouragement and advocate for equal rights for women regardless of area of medical work.
I believe that Elizabeth Blackwell would definitely join this organization because: she too, sought to create institutions that would focus on benefitting women and children; she would have wanted a support center to help her in her male-dominated world and she believed in women’s right to advance their careers. Elizabeth would have wanted this association to help pursue women’s equal opportunity to enter medical schools and provide support for women trying to create their own practices and medical hospitals.
Elizabeth Blackwell is honored with the privilege of being the first recognized female doctor in the US. Elizabeth Blackwell had to work harder than any man to earn the recognition and success that she did. Her life revolved around her fierce desire to help women progress into the field of medical work. Elizabeth’s beliefs were not the stereotypical harsh feminist beliefs that her other aspiring colleges possessed. Elizabeth used her femininity and nurturing to her advantage. She believed that a woman’s instinct to care was what made women better suited for the medical field. She was also not fond of nurses. She wanted all of her students to aspire to heal and cure the sick, not take care of them while they were ill. Elizabeth set up a college for women going into the medical field and also, along with her sister and a friend, set up a woman-run hospital in New York. Although she used to hate medical work, her change in heart led her to tremendous success. One of her mentionable successes was her push for hygienic awareness. She tried to spread the word that poor health was not due to an angry god or bad luck, but rather due to unsanitary habits, which took a toll on the body. She realized well before many other doctors that illness treatment and prevention rested solely on sanitary habits.
Primary Source:
1) Blackwell, Elizabeth. “Ship Fever”. The Western Journal of Medicine and Surgery 1840-1949. Pp. 347
Secondary Source:
2) Wirtzfeld, Debrah A., “The History of Women in Surgery”, Can J Surg, Vol. 52, No. 4, Pp317-318
3) Morantz-Sanchez, Regina. “Feminist Theory and Historical Practice: Rereading Elizabeth Blackwell”, History and Theory, Vol. 31, No. 4 1992, pp 51-60
4) Borst, Charlotte. “As Patients and Healers: The History of Women and Medicine”, OAH Magazine of History, Vol. 19, No. 5 2005, pp 23-26
5) Monteiro, Lois A., “On Separate Roads: Florence Nightingale and Elizabeth Blackwell”, Signs Vol. 9, No. 3 1984: pp 520-533
6) Morantz, Regina Markell. “Feminism, Professionalism, and Germs: The Thought of Mary Putnam Jacobi and Elizabeth Blackwell” American Quarterly Vol. 35, No. 5 1982. Pp 459-478
Borst, Charlotte. “As Patients and Healers: The History of Women and Medicine”, OAH Magazine of History, Vol. 19, No. 5 2005, pp 23-26
Borst’s article told of the success and accomplishments of Elizabeth Blackwell throughout her medical career. Borst explained Blackwell’s thoughts on why women should be treated by other female doctors, on Blackwell’s belief that women’s nurturing nature was better suited for the medical practice and on the continuing progress made in female medical education since Blackwell’s push for equality. Borst writes that Blackwell broke through the stereotypes of the era and forged a new path for ambitious women, including her younger sister who went on to be a doctor as well.
Borst’s article, though focused on women in medicine throughout all of history, managed to focus a great deal of deserved attention to Elizabeth Blackwell who’s contributions to the medical field were of great importance.
Wirtzfeld, Debrah A., “The History of Women in Surgery”, Can J Surg, Vol. 52, No. 4, Pp317-318
Wirtzfeld gave an over view of the events which inspired Elizabeth Blackwell to pursue medical work though she had been denied for over 20 schools due to her gender. She described Blackwell’s actions upon being accepted to a medical college in New York. Blackwell opened a college of medicine for women and was an advocate of interpersonal relationships in the doctor-patient relationship. Wirtzfeld stated that Blackwell was an inspiration to all women pursuing careers in fields that posed a challenge. Blackwell eventually was honored as the fit woman Medical Doctor in the US In 1889, says Wirzfeld, and there is now an award given in her name.
Wirtzfeld’s article, though giving only a an overview of many women medical doctors, did do a good job in briefly outlining the influences for Blackwell and Blackwell’s achievements.
Blackwell, Elizabeth. “Ship Fever”. The Western Journal of Medicine and Surgery 1840-1949. Pp. 347
Elizabeth Blackwell discussed her experiences in dealing with a Typhus epidemic. She described how the epidemic was largely brought to the United States by poor, Irish immigrants. In her article, Blackwell talked about the possible ways a person could be infected with the disease, how the disease presented itself, describes the symptoms, treatments and precautions to take so as not to be infected. She detailed impressively the symptoms, effects, precautions and causes for the disease. Blackwell went so far as to describe her autopsy findings and conclusions about the progression of the disease. She strongly argued that hygienic means were the best way to recover and prevent the disease.
Blackwell’s article was well written and conveyed in an understandable way and spoke volumes about her methods of healing, dedication to progress and was informative.
Monteiro, Lois A., “On Separate Roads: Florence Nightingale and Elizabeth Blackwell”, Signs Vol. 9, No. 3 1984: pp 520-533
Montiero’s article focuses mainly on the relationship and divergent paths of Elizabeth Blackwell and Florence Nightingale. Montiero provides that Blackwell was the first American female physician. She also says that Blackwell contributed to a major breakthrough in the fight for women’s rights in England and the US. Montiero discussed the long seven year battle that Blackwell waged after graduating medical school to begin her own practice and hopefully woman-run hospital. She explained in simple yet informative detail Blackwell’s goals for her hospital. She states that Blackwell wanted to teach women how to be doctors, treat the sick and cure the ill. Blackwell’s goals were not to have women caring for the sick and making a healthier environment for the sick.
Montiero’s article was a fairly good resource for insights into Elizabeth Blackwell’s personality and goals for her hospital.
Morantz, Regina Markell. “Feminism, Professionalism, and Germs: The Thought of Mary Putnam Jacobi and Elizabeth Blackwell” American Quarterly Vol. 35, No. 5 1982. Pp 459-478
Morantz’s article discusses the mindset of Elizabeth Blackwell and her colleague who’s mindset was far harsher than Blackwell’s. Morantz says that Blackwell was a “sanitarian” and believed that poor health was not the punishment of God, but rather the effect of poor hygiene and could be controlled by living in a healthier way. As Morantz states, the major concerns for Blackwell were how women would fit into the medical field and how physicians would adapt to society.
Morantz’s article was informative however not well organized and it’s effectiveness of providing information on Blackwell.
Morantz-Sanchez, Regina. “Feminist Theory and Historical Practice: Rereading Elizabeth Blackwell”, History and Theory, Vol. 31, No. 4 1992, pp 51-60
Sanchez states in her article that Blackwell was more prone to “relativity” than “objectivity” which was the practice that was becoming more and more widely taught and used. She states that Blackwell believed that the objectivity of medicine and the relationship between doctor and patient was dangerous and materialistic and too rationalistic. Blackwell surprisingly guessed correctly that objectivity would become the norm by the end of the century. Sanchez tells that Blackwell’s belief was that there was God-given attributes in females and emphasized that there were differences between men and women. Sanchez points out that Blackwell was America’s first woman doctor, a huge feat, and used her influence to help bring social change about for women. Sanchez informs her audience that Blackwell believed in individual treatment per patient and that sanitary habits were important.
Sanchez’s article was extremely well written and provided a plethora of well organized information on the practices, life, beliefs and knowledge of Elizabeth Blackwell.